We use cookies to help improve and maintain our site. More information.

February 21, 2019

Sound and fury, but Brexit reality unchanged

Not a lot happened in the UK yesterday - not really. We think it is best to ignore the new centrist party because it will not affect Brexit one way or the other, nor do we see any evidence of a groundswell of public support. When one of the new Conservative members of the now 11-strong independent group used the occasion to emphasise her support for fiscal austerity, politics as usual returned. The honeymoon period - or rather the mourning period - ended on the second day of this new group. 

After the three defections, the effective Conservative majority is now 323 to 318 votes. Dominic Grieve, the former attorney general, said last night that he too would resign from the Tories, but only if the government proposes to leave the EU with no deal.

If that were the case, he would not be the only one. So one of the firmer conclusions we draw immediately is that, if the Tories wanted to pursue a no-deal Brexit, they would need to have elections first. The reverse order makes no sense - elections in the middle of no-deal chaos.

So, where are we now? Theresa May's visit to Brussels yesterday yielded no concrete results - unsurprisingly. The technical talks will continue, but no agreement is expected by next week. The Sun reports that ministers want May to commit to an extension in case of no deal, or else she will see ministers supporting the Cooper amendment. We think this is a promise she can easily give. The Cooper amendment might still pass, as there is more support for it now than three weeks ago. But the amendment has lost much of its political significance. Back then, it was regarded as a proxy for a second referendum. This is no longer so.

Here are our three main Brexit scenarios:

  • May brings a new deal mid-March. Deal passes. Government fast-tracks ratification. UK leaves on March 29. 
  • no agreement until final marathon at or around EU summit on March 21-22. Meaningful vote delayed until end March. Deal passes. Short technical extension;
  • Meaningful vote fails in either of the two scenarios. At this point elections are very likely.

What about the Cooper bill? If the meaningful vote is lost, it would force the government to make an official request to extend the Art. 50 deadline (preceded by a symbolic vote on whether the parliament actively supports a no-deal Brexit). It is possible that EU and UK agree a different period than the one specified in the bill. The EU is also free to attach conditions. 

Does the government have the ability to frustrate the Cooper bill? The bill is well-drafted and has no obvious loopholes. But it is not a fail-safe mechanism either. The government could: 

  • ask for a short extension before bill takes effect, which would supersede Cooper;
  • Cooper takes effect, meaningful vote is lost. Parliament forces elections. May would request short extension, Cooper bill mechanisms would be superseded in that case too;
  • House of Lords filibuster to delay introduction of the bill until after meaningful vote;
  • government could try to take legal action against the bill, or simply refuse to act on it, and deliberately cause a constitutional crisis;
  • or it could co-opt the EU to frustrate the bill, either by trying to organise a veto of a single member state in the European Council, or to frustrate it in the negotiations with the European Council;
  • we are, for now, disregarding more extreme measures such a prorogation or other means that would involve the Queen in her role as head of state.

It will probably not come to any of this, but this list may still constitute a useful warning to anybody who believes that Cooper is a fail-safe mechanism towards a Brexit reversal or a second referendum. 

Show Comments Write a Comment

February 21, 2019

Supertanker Deutschland moves to join internet age

It is a smallish, essentially domestic piece of news that encapsulates much of what is wrong with Germany – and perhaps we should add: in it. As FAZ tells us, leading politicians of both main parties have declared themselves delighted with a decision to change the constitution so that the Bund or federal state may help its constituent Länder with the financing of public services and policies that had until now fallen fully within the (jealously guarded) sovereignty of said Länder. This means the Bund can now help the Länder with public housing programmes, proximity transport and, crucially, public education. A main consequence of the change is that federal Germany will soon be able to assist its member states with ushering their schools more fully into the internet age, a whopping twenty years after the start of that new epoch by the most conservative estimates.

When Germany gets its act together, stuff (usually) happens, and tends mostly to happen comparatively well. The main problem of the consensus-driven supertanker Bundesrepublik Deutschland is the time it takes to get the German act together.

Show Comments Write a Comment

This is the public section of the Eurointelligence Professional Briefing, which focuses on the geopolitical aspects of our news coverage. It appears daily at 2pm CET. The full briefing, which appears at 9am CET, is only available to subscribers. Please click here for a free trial, and here for the Eurointelligence home page.


Recent News

  • February 21, 2019
  • Sound and fury, but Brexit reality unchanged
  • Supertanker Deutschland moves to join internet age
  • February 19, 2019
  • Neither seven dwarfs, nor the magnificent seven. Merely a sad day for Labour
  • Will Costa last through the stand-off with the unions?
  • February 18, 2019
  • How the splits on the left and the right will affect Brexit
  • February 15, 2019
  • Syriza suffers defeat in constitutional reform
  • A cautionary tale about experts
  • February 14, 2019
  • What will Jeremy Corbyn do?
  • Juppé, now a sage rather than Macron's man in the EP
  • February 13, 2019
  • What to make of the man in the pub - and other tales
  • Macron loses more early advisers - or cuts them loose